An Apple a Day Is Fine, but Know Where Your Apple Has Been
The old saying "an apple a day keeps the doctor away" has done more for apples than any marketing campaign. Apples are genuinely good food: fibre, especially the soluble fibre pectin, vitamin C and plant compounds concentrated in the skin. But the apple on your plate in March may not be the same fruit your grandparents ate.
My view: an apple a day is fine, but know where your apple has been.
The journey of an apple
Indian apples are harvested from July to October in Himachal Pradesh, Jammu and Kashmir and Uttarakhand. Apples sold months later are usually from cold storage or controlled-atmosphere storage, which slows ripening. Imported apples from the USA, New Zealand, Chile, Iran and elsewhere fill the rest of the year. Stored apples are safe, but they lose some crunch, flavour and vitamin C over time.
About that shine
Apples produce a natural wax. After washing, many packers add a thin food-grade wax coating to replace it and keep the fruit fresh and glossy. FSSAI permits certain waxes, such as beeswax, carnauba wax and shellac, but requires labelling. The concern is unlabelled or non-food-grade wax.
To be safer:
- Rub the apple with your nail; a thick white residue suggests heavy wax.
- Wash in warm water and scrub gently; a little baking soda in water may help remove surface residue.
- Buy seasonal Indian apples when available.
To peel or not to peel
The skin holds much of the fibre and antioxidants. I prefer to wash well and eat the skin. If you're worried about wax or pesticides on a particular batch, peeling is a reasonable compromise. You lose some nutrients but still get the fruit.
Apple seeds
Seeds contain a compound that can release cyanide when crushed. Swallowing a few whole seeds by accident isn't dangerous, but don't grind them into smoothies.
Is an apple better than other fruit?
Not really. A guava, an orange or a handful of jamun gives you as much or more nutrition, often at a lower price and from closer to home (see guava). The "apple a day" idea came from Wales, not from any special magic. The real lesson is to eat a fruit a day, or several.
Make the most of apples
- Whole apple as a mid-morning snack
- Sliced with peanut butter for children
- Grated into oats or raita
- Baked into a comforting crumble once in a while
Final word
Choose crisp, fragrant Indian apples in season, wash them well, and eat them whole. Out of season, don't feel obliged to buy shiny imports when local fruit is on the cart.
I am the Chief Physician, Anaesthesiology at Asklepios Klinik Altona, Hamburg. I graduated from LMU Munich with a State Examination in Medicine and completed the specialist training in Anaesthesiology at LMU University Hospital Munich. I am originally from Munich, Bavaria. After my training at LMU University Hospital Munich I have worked for 15 years in this role. My areas of interest are anaesthesia, intensive care and emergency medicine.