Chole Bhature Should Stay a Weekend Treat, and I Will Defend That
Some dishes are built for every day. Chole bhature is not one of them, and I think that is part of its charm. When a plate of puffed bhature arrives with dark, tangy chole, sliced onions and a green chilli on the side, it feels like an occasion. Eat it every Tuesday and it becomes ordinary.
So here is my view: cook it on a Sunday morning, share it with people, and enjoy it without guilt. Just don't make it your weekday lunch.
For the chole (serves 4)
- 1½ cups kabuli chana, soaked overnight
- 2 black tea bags or 1 tbsp loose tea tied in muslin (for the dark colour)
- 2 onions, 2 tomatoes, 1 tbsp ginger-garlic paste
- 2 tbsp chole masala, 1 tsp amchur, ½ tsp black salt
- 1 tsp cumin, 2 bay leaves, 1 black cardamom
- 3 tbsp oil, salt
For the bhature
- 2 cups maida (or half maida, half whole wheat)
- ½ cup thick curd, ½ tsp baking soda, 1 tsp sugar, salt
- 1 tbsp oil, water as needed, oil for frying
Method
- Knead the bhatura dough with curd, soda, sugar, salt and oil into a soft dough. Cover and rest for 2 to 3 hours. The resting gives the puff.
- Pressure-cook the chana with tea bags and salt for 5 to 6 whistles. Remove the tea bags.
- In a heavy kadai, heat oil and add cumin, bay leaf and black cardamom. Fry onions until brown, then ginger-garlic paste and tomatoes until the masala darkens and dries.
- Add chole masala, amchur and black salt, then the chana with some cooking water. Mash a few chickpeas. Simmer for 15 minutes until thick.
- Divide the dough into balls, roll into ovals about the thickness of a coin, and slide into very hot oil. Press gently with the back of a slotted spoon so they balloon. Fry until pale golden.
Making peace with the heaviness
I won't pretend this is light food. Bhature are deep-fried, and maida digests quickly and spikes blood sugar. A few things help without ruining the dish:
- Use half whole-wheat flour. The bhature are slightly less fluffy but still lovely.
- Fry at the right temperature. Oil that isn't hot enough soaks into the dough.
- Serve more chole and fewer bhature. Two bhature with a generous bowl of chana is a better balance than four.
- Add pickled onions and a lemon wedge. The acidity cuts the richness.
The chole on its own is genuinely nourishing: chickpeas are full of protein and fibre. On weekdays, eat the same chole with a phulka or with jeera rice and you get most of the joy.
My verdict: protect chole bhature's status as a celebration dish. It tastes better when it is something you look forward to.
I am a Senior Accountant at Ghazanfar Group, Mazar-i-Sharif, with 7 years of experience in accounting, payroll and tax filing. I graduated from Balkh University with a bachelor's degree in Economics. Outside work I enjoy reading novels and cooking traditional food.