---
title: "Why India and China Can Never Fully Trust Each Other"  
description: "An opinion on why India and China find it hard to trust each other, covering 1962, Galwan 2020, the border, the trade deficit, China’s ties with Pakistan."  
author: "Cooper Ryan"  
published: 2026-11-14  
canonical: https://yourviews.mindstick.com/view/93656/why-india-and-china-can-never-fully-trust-each-other  
category: "World Politics and History"  
tags: ["India China relations", "Galwan clash", "LAC border", "India China trade deficit", "Brahmaputra dam", "China Pakistan", "India foreign policy opinion"]  
reading_time: 4 minutes  

---

# Why India and China Can Never Fully Trust Each Other

In September 2026, Prime Minister Modi and President Xi met in New Delhi at the BRICS summit and agreed that “differences should not become disputes.” A year earlier, they had met in Tianjin. Flights between the two countries have resumed after years. Indian pilgrims are going to Kailash Mansarovar again.

All of this is good news, and I welcome it. But when I ask myself whether India and China can ever truly trust each other, my honest answer is no, not fully. Here is why.

## The Shadow of 1962

India’s first big lesson in trusting China came painfully. In the 1950s, the slogan was **“Hindi-Chini bhai bhai.”** In 1962, China attacked across the Himalayas and India suffered a humiliating defeat. For many Indians, that betrayal shaped how we see China for the next sixty years.

## A Border That Isn’t Agreed

India and China share a disputed frontier of more than 3,400 kilometres. There is no agreed line on the ground, only a **Line of Actual Control** that each side reads differently. That means patrols meet, face-offs happen and both sides keep building roads, airstrips and villages.

The worst moment in decades came in **June 2020 at Galwan**, when 20 Indian soldiers died in hand-to-hand fighting, and China lost soldiers too. The standoff lasted years. The disengagement agreements reached since 2024 have reduced tension, but troops on both sides remain in large numbers.

## China’s Closeness to Pakistan

China is Pakistan’s most important partner. It supplies weapons, builds infrastructure under the **China-Pakistan Economic Corridor**, which passes through Pakistan-occupied Kashmir, and often shields Pakistan diplomatically. During the 2025 conflict after Pahalgam, Indian forces faced Chinese-made systems on the other side. It is hard to trust a country that arms your most hostile neighbour.

## Water Worries

China controls the upper reaches of rivers that flow into India, including the **Brahmaputra** (Yarlung Tsangpo). In 2025, China began work on a giant hydropower project in Tibet near the Indian border. Beijing says it will not harm downstream countries, but without clear data-sharing and binding agreements, India and Bangladesh worry.

## A Lopsided Trade Relationship

India buys far more from China than it sells. In 2025-26, India’s trade deficit with China was more than 110 billion dollars. Our factories depend on Chinese components, chemicals for medicines, solar parts and electronics. That dependence makes India vulnerable, and it makes many Indians uneasy.

## Competing for the Same Space

Both countries want to lead Asia and speak for the developing world. China blocks India’s permanent seat on the UN Security Council and its entry into the Nuclear Suppliers Group. India stays out of China’s **Belt and Road Initiative** and works with the US, Japan and Australia in the **Quad**. Each sees the other as a rival for influence in South Asia, Africa and the Indian Ocean.

## Why We Still Need Engagement

None of this means India should treat China as an enemy. China is a huge market, a technology powerhouse and a neighbour we cannot move away from. Stable relations reduce the risk of war and help Indian businesses. The recent thaw is sensible, especially as the US has become a less predictable partner.

## My Approach: Talk, Trade, Prepare

- **Keep talking** at every level, so crises don’t spiral.
- **Trade smartly**, reducing dependence in critical areas like electronics, APIs and solar.
- **Strengthen the border**, with roads, technology and well-equipped forces.
- **Build partnerships** with other countries, without becoming anyone’s junior ally.

## The Other View

Some argue that India’s own suspicion is part of the problem, and that bolder economic engagement, including more Chinese investment in Indian factories, would benefit both and build trust over time. Others in China say India’s closeness to the US is the real obstacle. These views have some logic, and trust is always built on both sides. But history, geography and power politics make me believe India should engage China with open eyes, a warm handshake and a firm guard.

---

Original Source: https://yourviews.mindstick.com/view/93656/why-india-and-china-can-never-fully-trust-each-other

Copyright © MindStick Software Pvt. Ltd. This Markdown version is provided for developers, AI systems, and offline reading.
